Investigation Finds Key West Inmates Filed False Tax Returns From Jail
Our West Palm Beach tax fraud criminal defense attorneys were extremely interested in a Feb. 21 Miami Herald article about an unusual tax fraud scheme. According to the article, inmates at the Monroe County Jail near Key West ran a large-scale tax fraud scheme netting nearly $1 million in bogus refunds. The participants were not in jail for tax fraud, and in most cases have moved on to prison for unrelated crimes since the crimes were uncovered nearly three years ago. But while they were in jail, about 50 inmates were able to claim refunds for taxes they never paid, “automatically deducted” from paychecks that never existed. The article says this is a growing problem in jails and prisons around the nation.
Investigators say two inmates served as ringleaders in the schemes, and even charged other inmates for information on how it worked. Shawn Clarke and Danilo Suarez filed 1040EZ forms along with Form 4852, which is a self-reported substitute for a W-2. Participants fabricated their information, claiming to have worked for companies that don’t really exist, sometimes while they were in jail. Some filed multiple returns despite having never before filed tax returns, claiming an average of about $5,000 in returns. Jail officials uncovered the scheme in late 2006 when they found a written document in a cell, and handed the IRS a case complete with confessions and recordings of incriminating phone calls. Local officials complain that the federal government has delayed the case for years, bringing evidence before a grand jury only this month.
As Miami tax fraud criminal defense lawyers, we’re pleased that the federal government is prosecuting this well-documented case. (However, we’d like to note that jailhouse confessions are unreliable, because prisoners can be under duress.) But if authorities start seriously pursing tax fraud from jails and prisons, we’re concerned that inmates who make honest mistakes may get swept up in the investigations. The article notes that some of the inmates in this case had never filed tax returns before. The tax code is notoriously complicated and confusing; it must be even more confusing for those with no past tax experience, some of whom may never have held a legal job. Such inmates may also honestly rely on bad advice from people like Clarke and Suarez. It would be a shame to criminally prosecute such a person for trying to do the right thing.
Continue reading "Investigation Finds Key West Inmates Filed False Tax Returns From Jail" »


